Navigation Menu

[Richard]

MatDerKater wrote:

Dude.

Granted, I only just got here…waited 5 days for them to give me access to the course, and now I probably have to wait another 5 to get access to the stream….but this shit is fkn dynamite….PROVIDING you are already a decent trader.

Check the image. It is a screengrab from the EURUSD from early this afternoon, when Djamal made a short YouTube video describing all the component parts of the MK-Indicator.

Look at the red circled Mid Term Short SL tranche just above price. Look at the red circled Mid Term Long SL Tranche way down below price.

Now go and look at what the EURUSD went and done. Every fucking retail trader in the EURUSD (and many others) got taken to the cleaners for sure this afternoon. Yet the MK-Indicator shone a light not just on how a trader could have avoided the dickfuckery, but also on how a trader could have profited from it. Fk knows where Djamal is getting his orderflow data from, or if it isn’t actual real orderflow data, fk knows how he has constructed some statistical model that very closely resembles genuine order flow data, but the fact is, he has, and it is there, and in the right hands, could be used to great effect.

The other screenshot is a trade I took, based on that sneak glimpse of the MK Indicator in real time. I just shot for a bottom of the range target, and not a direct hit of the ‘Longies’ way down below.

It is understandable to have cynicism in the trading sector when it comes to trading educators, or someone trying to sell indicators, as most are fucking terrible…….But I feel that SME-FX has something of real value to any competent trader here. And I feel the dishevelled disorganised nature of his material, his website, and the ‘support’, and his fairly low volume of followers, is rather more a reassurance than an offput. Beware the slick marketed trading gurus with 750K followers on YouTube. If they went to all that trouble to make something so readily appealing and easily digestible, good chance it’s because it’s shit, and cos it’s bad for you.

Do yourself a favour and fork out a small bit of money, check out the video course, then see if you can’t make it work for you. If you can’t, then you have wasted a very modest sum of money. No big deal.

Matthew Toomey, PLEASE refrain from polluting this topic.
Thank you.

@Admin SME still I haven’t gotten any answer to my concerns.

[Richard]

Admin SME wrote:

Richard,

most live trades entailed a number of videos, these spread over several days. Within each video, Djamal first quotes the precise time (to the minute) and the current price.
As you can see from the upload dates / times, these videos were immediately uploaded, often with just seconds of delay.
So how could this be “faked” in any way?

SME FX

First of all, he never shows fullscreen, only price charts and indicators I mean there is no info on account type and whether this is realtime or PLAYBACK and this is essential for the sake of transparency. I can make millions on playback every single day as many youtube ”market wizards” do, everyone knows that market is all about timing, so if you post videos AFTER the fact you can FAKE it within minutes or seconds if you are smart enough.
The most important thing is proof of performance which is the brokerage statement which is missing here. (and this one can be faked too).
Today everyone can be whoever they want to be. It’s easy. I have seen many LinkedIn accounts that were FAKED since there is no one who checks reliability of information that is there. Many people put some well-known universities and big banks in their portfolios simply because they can (like infamous Michael V. who promotes order flow with his magickal indicators)

There are also a few more things in his videos that raise concern but I will keep it to myself.

so…talking about experience is not enough. He has to show it and prove it with no room for any DOUBT.

If he manages to do it, I will be his huge admirer forever.

[Richard]

Christopher Miranda wrote:

Fellas, you can believe what you like. Most of us here have been following Djamal/smefx since he started his thread on forexfactory in 2018. Everything else is just noise and theories.
He’s been showing his proof on youtube since 2015, and it has truly always been incredible to watch and especially to be here. I’m not involved in their business at all, I’m just another stranger, so don’t expect info that you cannot already find here on the forums, on youtube, or through searching online, because everything we need to know has already been made available, it just takes the time to see it all.

I don’t know who you are. You might be a stranger or a person who cooperates with this guy. I don’t know who you are. Saying that you are a stranger doesn’t necessarily mean that you are one, anyway, can you post a link to proof, a YT video, or whatever that shows him trading LIVE? I mean something that is being uploaded while he trading, not AFTER the fact.

[Richard]

MatDerKater wrote:

Perhaps he has a deal with a ‘special one’, who does indeed have a data feed showing a forex trading desk’s FULL orderflow information, to the extent of even showing where the SL orders are.

At the end of the day, IF he can sit and profitably trade these coloured order bars on the right hand side of the screen, then they must be pertaining to something relevant.

Of course, I am yet to come to any sort of conclusion on anything here, but I saw a few of Djamal’s videos, and what he describes about how the markets are moved around I instinctively know, is what it likely all boils down to, the majority of the time….so paid for the video course to at least check out what it is all about….a video course I have not yet been given access to…….

…….and the question remains…..how come some retail trader has access to as privileged insider information as where STOP orders are?

If everyone could have this sort of information on their screens, the game would soon be up (providing it was accurate).

In the financial world, everything costs money, much more than £50 a month … I guess. There are many market wizards/educators who claim they possess something that others don’t so I am always a bit skeptical.
I don’t say it’s a scam but I can’t find any proof, like brokerage statements or live videos on YT where you can clearly see that he is trading on REAL account, not a playback demo, because his videos are uploaded not streamed.

[Richard]

MatDerKater wrote:

oh….I wouldn’t have thought that.

I would have thought that the indicators would be available, to those who paid their £50 per month subscription….i.e. ‘rent’ the indicator.

….At the end of the day, it isn’t the indicator, but the connection to actual Forex volume data that is key here…….am still wondering how Djamal can get access to FX orderflow data when almost nobody else can, since the banks don’t release it….especially the data on where the Stop Losses are…..I would have thought that information like that is for the special few.

Yes, it seems like snake oil.

[Richard]

”The contact form is in the main menu, or the “Contact Us” button at the bottom of every single page on this entire website” Thanks! found it. There is some problem with the website, it looks scatty, I don’t know if it’s my browser’s fault or something else. I rarely see problems like this.
”It’s almost as if you didn’t bother to look at a single thread or video before making this post” well I did!
”The indicators are not available to anyone” who can get indicators then?

[Author]

Posts